Pauline made a very excellent point the other day about Christine Baranski. For those who don’t recognize the name, she plays the reoccurring part of Leonard’s mother on ‘The Big Bang Theory’. However, she is best known for her work on ‘Cybil’ and in films like ‘Chicago’, ‘The Grinch who Stole Christmas’ and ‘Mama Mia’. Or, if you’re my son Grayson, you would remember her voice work from classics like ‘Scooby Doo in Where's My Mummy?’
Christine Baranski is extremely talented and the Emmy voters love nominating her. Since ‘Cybil’ she’s been nominated three times in the ‘Outstanding Guest Actress in a Comedy’ category, once for ‘Frasier’ and twice for ‘The Big bang Theory’. PLUS, this year she was ALSO nominated as ‘Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series’ for her work on ‘The Good Wife.’
Now, to answer Pauline’s question about the competition… the ‘Guest Actress in a Comedy’ category was completely stacked to the gills with talent this year. All seven women are past Emmy winners (Jane Lynch was the only one without an Emmy going into the 2010 Awards, but she won Best Supporting Actress in a Comedy that night for ‘Glee’).
Needless to say, the competition was rough.
However, I really hate to be cynical, but Character Actors don’t normally win the Guest Actor/Actress categories. The awards normally go to Sentimental Favorites or Hollywood Heavyweights. Aka, it normally goes to a household name.
Case in point, since 2000, here are the big names who won for best Guest Star:
Actor in a Comedy: Bruce Willis, Anthony LaPagila, Stanley Tucci, Gene Wilder, Tim Conway, John Turturro, Justin Timberlake, and Neil Patrick Harris.
Actor in a Drama: Ray Liotta, Charles S. Dutton (twice for two different shows!), John Goodman, William Shatner, Michael J. Fox, and John Lithgow (BTW: do you guys remember my post about John Lithgow in ‘Dexter’ last real? I predicted this win… however, he was in almost every episode. He should have been in the Supporting category, not the Guest category)’
Actress in a Drama: Sally Field. Patricia Clarkson (twice), Alfre Woodard, Cynthia Nixon, Sharon Stone, Ellen Burstyn, and Ann-Margret.
Actress in a Comedy: Jean Smart (twice), Cloris Leachman (twice), Christina Applegate, Laura Linney,Elaine Stritch, Tina Fey, and Betty White.
As you can see… the Guest category isn’t used to champion raw up-incoming talent or those brilliant actors who have toiled away in relative anonymity for years playing bit parts. No, it’s normally given to a household name as a gift… as if to say, “Thank you for still working”, or “Thanks for putting your movie career aside to work on the small screen for a week”.
Even wins that people could conceive as being an upset, really aren’t. In 2005, Bobby Cannavale took home the Guest Actor in a Comedy award over Alec Baldwin, Victor Garber, Jeff Goldblum, and Fred Willard. On the surface, Bobby was a huge underdog. However, in 2004, Bobby Cannavale was the darling of the international film festival circuit for his work in the Independent Film Masterpiece ‘The Station Agent’. (If you have seen it, you should!) Bobby has been on television for years… in ‘Third Watch’ and ‘100 Centre Street’… however, the Emmy’s never recognized him for his talent until after he made a name for himself on the big screen.
I know! I’m being cynical. However, there are exceptions!
In 2001, Michael Emerson, who later became Benjamin on ‘Lost’ won for his work as a serial killer on ‘The Practice’. He edged out James Cromwell, Patrick Dempsey, and Oliver Platt.
In 2006, Christian Clemenson took down Michael J. Fox and James Woods for his work on ‘Boston Legal’ as Jerry ‘Hands’ Espinson. Incidentally, his popularity and Emmy win led creator David E. Kelly to promote Christian to a full cast member for the shows two remaining seasons.
And my favorite underdog of them all has actually won TWICE! I’m talking about, none other than, Kathryn Joosten who plays Mrs. McClusky on ‘Desperate Housewives’. Kathryn has been working steady since the mid 80s and has never done more than a hand full of episodes on any one show except for ‘The West Wing’ and ‘Desperate Housewives’. I hate to admit that I watch, but Kathryn is the best thing about ‘Desperate Housewives’, Mrs. Mclusky is one of the best characters on television… and THANK THE LORD! Kathryn was recently promoted to a fulltime Housewife!
Sadly, I can only point out 3 significant ‘upsets’ over the last ten years in four different Guest categories.