Ummm… yeah… so this show is still on? Hasn’t “Dancing with the Stars” run its course? Sure, Serena and I watched this show religiously… for a while. However, as the seasons have progressed the producers of DWTS seem to be loosening the definition of its key component: “Star”.
This season boasts 11 contestants… and frankly, only 3 of them are interesting:
1) Buzz Aldrin, celebrating the 50 year anniversary of the moon landings.
2) Evan Lysacek, right on the heels of Gold Medal in Vancouver.
3) Chad Ochocinco, the hilarious Wide-Receiver from the Cincinnati Bengals.
These three guys make the cut in my books. They are relevant. Now let’s take a moment to discuss the irrelevant:
1) Jake Pavelka, last season’s “Bachelor”… I’m not quite sure… but I checked my watch and it looks like Jake already used his 15 minutes.
2) Kate Gosselin, another reality show “star” who hasn’t gotten the memo. Hell, I think she stole my 15 minutes!
3) Niecy Nash, Huh? The reality show host from TLC? What, DWTS felt the need for the trifecta of lame? A reality contestant, a reality doc subject, AND a reality host?
4) Pamela Anderson, besides being a testament of Disney Corp’s family values, do you know what Pamela’s last television project was? Two years ago Pamela was a contestant on Big Brother – Australia. She was voted out in three days. And we all know about her reality video.
5) Shannon Doherty, Okay it’s getting even more annoying… Shannon makes the THIRD Beverly Hills 90210 alum to complete on DWTS… However, not to be outdone, Shannon has also posed for Playboy AND hosted a reality show on Syfy! Oh… and she “done time”… as we learned from Little Kim, American’s love women who’ve been in prison.
6) Erin Andrews, Ummm… she’s an ESPN reporter… who also has a Playboy connection… who made headlines when someone released an unauthorized “peepshow” video of her in a hotel room. So… I guess she’s done reality television too.
7) Aiden Turner, an out of work Soap Actor. Seriously, he left ABC’s “All My Children” in December to pursue other projects… like… other DWTS.
Frankly, it seems like what started out as a good idea has become the place where reality stars and out of work actors go to die. My neighbor’s dad was recently interviewed by a local news station while on a fishing trip. Honestly, he has more credentials than some of these jokers!
The most perplexing member of this motley crew is the eleventh and final contestant: Nicole Scherzinger, a professional singer and dancer who has toured with Lady Gaga, Britney Spears, and is currently “frontwoman” for the Pussycat Dolls. Or as I like to refer to her: “The Ringer”.
Honestly folks, is there any redeeming quality to DWTS anymore? The formula is so great! But it is losing relevance.
When “The Mole” and “The Apprentice” started losing viewership they turned away from “average-joe” contestants and embraced the VH1 way of doing things by championing Celebrity Editions. This works for them because their shows were crap to begin with.
There is a reason why Survivor hasn’t done a Celebrity edition… and it’s not because they don’t have Celebrities interested in doing it… it’s because they don’t have too. The same thing goes with “The Amazing Race,” although they tend to throw in one or two pseudo-Celebrity teams each season… it doesn’t affect the relevancy of the show.
But DWTS has a proven formula comparable to Survivor, The Amazing Race, and American Idol. However, their formula has become flawed over time. The professional dancers have become more famous than the craptastic D-Grade Celebrities they are forced to dance with. This is a major problem and probably the root cause of my frustration with the show.
So, perhaps a shift in the opposite direction of “The Mole” would be successful. What makes reality television so great is getting to see ordinary people do extraordinary things... for money.
What do you think would happen to DWTS if they took 12 average folks, assigned them one of the professional dancers we all know and love, and said the winner gets a million dollars?
I, for one, predict higher ratings… which mean higher revenue generation via advertising sales.
But who am I to judge? I’d still just TiVo it and zip through the commercials.