Sunday, February 6, 2011

Day 931: 83rd Best Picture, Best Director, and Harry Potter

About a week ago I shared my first impressions of the 83rd annual Oscar nominations… however; I hadn’t seen all the movies on the list so my ability to speculate at that time was hampered.

Now that I’ve seen all 10 Best Picture and 5 Best Director nominations… I feel like I can weight in a little better… not that anyone cares, but this little movie mission of mine is a nice distraction… and Lord knows I need a distraction… so bear with me here.

BEST PICTURE
As it stands now, my personal favorite movie of the year is still ‘127 Hours’, however the odds of it winning Best Picture (or anything else) is slim to none. 

So, last week I predicted Best Picture as a tossup between ‘The Social Network’ and ‘The King’s Speech’ (even though I hadn’t seen ‘The King’s Speech’ yet).  And now that I HAVE seen the latter, I still believe it’s a tossup (like last year’s ‘Avatar’ v. ‘The Hurt Locker’ show down… which was hard to predict)… however, personally, I would give the edge to ‘The King’s Speech’.  There is nothing to dislike.  It’s just a delightfully well made film in the style of ‘Shakespeare in Love’ and ‘Forrest Gump’.  It is the kind of film made specifically to win awards produced by Harvey Weinstein… a producer has a knack for backing films that not only get nominated… but win awards (‘Shakespeare in Love’ is one of his).

Now, real contender’s aside, I have only found one film that I believe deserved a Best Picture courtesy nomination that was snubbed.  Now, it’s not the kind of film you might think.  I’m not talking about a movie that contains amazing Oscar nominated performances like ‘Rabbit Hole’ or ‘Blue Valentine’.  No… I’m talking about a completely different kind of movie.  A movie that will show off my total inner geek… I’m talking about ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1’.   

Yes, I’ve read all the books and yes, I would probably weep openly if I heard J.K. Rowling is releasing an eighth book in the series… but the movies, as a whole, have been a bit of a disappointment for me… that is until now… and I’m not surprised.  There has been an industry rumor surrounding the Harry Potter movies since the adaptation of the fourth book… and I’m not sure how accurate it is, but based on the two movie adaptation of the seventh and final book in the series I’m putting a certain amount of stock into the rumor I’m about to share.

The ‘legend’ all starts with screenwriter Steve Kloves, who worked closely with Rowlings adapting six of the seven books, (all but Book 5: ‘The Order of the Phoenix’).    His adaptations for the first two books were pretty straight forward and successful… however, Kloves was pretty open about his frustrations in adapting the third book, ‘Prisoner of Azkaban’, the point of the story where it becomes much darker, more complicated, and less family-fare.  And then, when it came time to adapt Book 4: ‘Goblet of Fire’, Kloves became very vocal about how the adaption of the book should be handled.  Kloves felt the story was too big for one movie and by cutting it down would cause continuity problems with the subsequent films.  So, he approached ‘Goblet of Fire’ director Mike Newell with an idea of making the book into two movies, with the first ending when Harry’s name is pulled from the Goblet.  Based on the rumor, Newell liked the idea and proposed it to the producers sighting the success of the Summer and Fall releases of The Matrix sequels in 2003.  Evidently, the producers weren’t interested in discussing the idea believing making two movies now would force them to make two for each of the remaining books.  They simply said, ‘Seven books, seven movies.”  And supposedly, Kloves, who had become very attached to the project, was less than pleased when the producers dismissed the idea so quickly.  And this is where the story takes two different paths.

Although, the reports surrounding the adaption of Book 5, ‘Order of the Phoenix’, states Kloves was unavailable due to the writers’ strike, the rumor goes on to say that Kloves attempted, once again, to talk the producers into breaking Book 5 up into two movies… and when his suggestion fell on deaf ears he used the strike as a way to separate himself from the project.

Then, in 2007, coinciding with the release of ‘Order of the Phoenix’, the final book, ‘The Deathly Hallows’, appeared in book stores…. At which point, according to the rumor, the producers realized they couldn’t finish the series properly with a total of seven movies… so they lured Kloves back to adapt the final two books into three movies.

I don’t know about the rest of you… but I always found the pacing of the Harry Potter movies to be insanely fast… Too fast.  Especially as they grew up… where the books were very thoughtfully paced, the movies were frantic as if they were trying to cram in as much information as possible into two and half hours… which is what they were trying to do.
But now, as a result of breaking ‘Deathy Hallows’ into two movies the pacing and tone of the films pretty much matches that of the book.  It’s REALLY good.  It’s great.  It’s what the series should have been ever since ‘Prisoner of Azkaban’.  And the film series has set itself up for an AMAZING end.  Although ‘Deathly Hallows, Part 1’ was overlooked this year… if Part 2 is anything like it… I would like to see a courtesy Best Picture nomination at the 84th Academy Awards.
BEST DIRECTOR
Just like Best Picture and what I said last week, this category is between David Fincher (The Social Network) and Tom Hooper (The King’s Speech).  However, unlike Best Picture, I’m giving David Fincher the edge this time.  Why?  Well… sometimes you have to look beyond the specific projects and focus on the nominee’s body of work.

‘The King’s Speech’ is great and Tom Hooper deserves the nomination, but this is only his third feature film.  Up until a little over a year ago Hooper has been, almost exclusively, a television director.  The Academy very rarely gives the Directing award to someone without an extensive resume… wins like Sam Mendes, who won for his directorial debut ‘American Beauty’, is very rare.

That said, this is David Fincher’s second Directing nomination, including ‘The Curious Case of Benjamin Button’.  Plus he’s been at the helm of numerous critically acclaimed movies like ‘Seven’, ‘Fight Club’, ‘Panic Room’, and ‘Zodiac’.  The guy makes excellent, thought provoking movies.  His resume gives him a distinct edge.

However… I am still very disappointed by the snubs of Danny Boyle (127 Hours) and Christopher Nolan (Inception).  Both movies were tremendously directed and if either were up against Fincher… I wouldn’t be able to predict who would come out on top… not that I have any real ability to predict now… but we’ll see how close I am on February 27th.

No comments: